Man on Valor
One of my favorite authors is Charles H. Freundlich. Like I. L. Peretz, author of “If Not Higher,” and Nobel Prize winner in Literature Isaac Bashevetz Singer, he writes not only fascinating short stories. He tells them in ways that prompt readers to recognize ideas that are generally overlooked but, when known and acted upon, will improve readers and their friends.
This tenth book by Freundlich, “Man of Valor,” continues his brilliant, entertaining, and mind-opening artistic work with six short tales. My favorite is “Rebellious Youth.” A well-meaning rabbi tries to discover why so many Modern Orthodox college-educated Jews are not observing all Jewish laws. He questions some of them and receives honest replies. He responds with traditional explanations to correct their thinking, which can be read as making matters worse; many of these responses are not very sensible to modern, educated youth. The tales make us realize that we need far better explanations.
I agree with Rabbi Asher Meza that less is more that that the rabbis instituted too many laws. We have 613 Torah laws plus thousands of rabbinical laws. I think many Jews don’t want to observe all the mitzvot and this is why many Jews are rather atheists or reform (that latter is a sort of buffet religion, pick and choose). While it is good to observe all of jewish law, as the rabbis explained them, and I even encourage it, I agree with Rabbi Asher. What do you think? Do you think better explanations would convince more Jews to observe the Halacha or should Judaism evolve and abrogate some laws like the ancient rabbis did when they did away with animal sacrifices?
I agree with what you suggest. Some of the laws are pure superstition invented by the public, and the rabbis allowed them.
The tales make us realize that we need far better explanations.
We must study hard to figure out the truth of the matter
I agree. We need to obey the laws but, at the same time, use our intelligence,
Dear Rabbi Israel Drazin ! Man of Valor” is a valuable contribution to contemporary Jewish literature. It challenges readers to think critically about faith, education, and the importance of adapting religious dialogue to better connect with the younger generation. Freundlich’s work is both insightful and inspiring, making it a highly recommended read for anyone interested in the dynamics of faith and modern life. Best, stephen